Selecting the appropriate welding method, TIG or laser, is crucial and depends on the specific requirements of the task at hand. Both techniques offer unique advantages, making each one more suitable for different applications. Let’s take a closer look at the differences between these methods to help you decide which one will be optimal in a given situation.
Laser Welding
Laser welding is an advanced welding technology that uses a concentrated beam of light (laser) to join materials. Thanks to its exceptional precision, it allows the creation of very narrow, deep, and strong welds with minimal heat impact on the surrounding material. It is an excellent choice when working with:
-
Heat-sensitive materials
-
Applications requiring the highest aesthetics and precision
-
Small and delicate components – the risk of thermal damage or deformation is significantly reduced
Key features of laser welding:
-
Versatility: Effective for welding various metals and their alloys (tool steel, stainless steel, aluminum, copper, titanium, etc.)
-
Minimal heat-affected zone: Reduces the risk of material deformation and structural changes
-
Clean process: Produces welds free from inclusions, holes, and microcracks
-
High precision: The use of microscopes (with magnification ×10 or more) allows precise operation and the use of very thin filler wires, even with a diameter of 0.2 mm
-
Automation: The process can be semi-automated (the operator controls a motorized head via joystick and manually adds filler material) or fully automated (e.g. Robolaser robotic stations)
TIG Welding
This popular method uses a non-consumable tungsten electrode to create an electric arc between the electrode and the workpiece. The arc’s heat melts the base material, and additional filler material (if used) is manually fed into the weld pool as wire. TIG welding is often chosen when:
-
Precision is important, though not as critical as with laser welding
-
High quality and clean welds are essential (though it typically requires more operator skill than laser welding)
-
A larger amount of filler material is needed or thicker components are being welded
Key features of TIG welding:
-
Versatility: Effective for welding various metals and alloys (stainless steel, aluminum, copper, titanium, etc.)
-
Process control: The operator has significant control over the weld pool, heat, and filler material addition
-
Thicker welds: Allows the use of thicker filler wires (up to 3 mm or more) and building up larger weld layers – useful for filling large gaps or cladding
-
Manual process: Typically a fully manual process, where the operator guides the TIG torch and feeds the filler wire by hand
Summary – When to Choose Laser or TIG Welding?
Choose laser welding if:
-
Maximum precision and a minimal heat-affected zone are priorities
-
You are working with small, thin, or delicate components
-
Minimal post-weld finishing is required
-
High welding speed is important (especially in automated applications)
-
Very narrow, deep, or hard-to-reach welds are needed
Choose TIG welding if:
-
High weld quality and good process control are needed, but extreme laser precision is not required
-
Thicker materials are being welded, or more filler material needs to be added (filling, cladding)
-
Lower service cost is a significant factor (compared to laser systems)
-
The work is primarily done manually
The final choice depends on the specific application, material, quality requirements, precision needs, budget, and the available skills of the operator.
